Exercising Before or After Eating: Debunking 5 Myths
|
|
Time to read 7 min
Introduction
One question always provokes controversy in fitness: Is exercising before or after eating better? With so much conflicting information, it's easy to be confused. Recognising how meal times and exercise impact your performance and energy levels can make a difference. Training during work or lunch helps you reach your goals— you just have to eat the right food at the right time.
Getting this right for women juggling busy schedules means more effective workouts without the guesswork. Let’s debunk five common myths and find the best approach for you!
Table of contents
Introduction Myth 1: Exercising Before or After Eating is Good. Benefits and Considerations of Exercising Before Breakfast Impact on Fat Metabolism During Workouts Myth 2: Eating Before a Workout Will Make You Feel Sluggish Recommended Meal Composition Before Exercising Effects of Carbohydrates and Protein on Energy Levels Myth 3: Post-Workout Nutrition Isn’t Important for Fat Loss Benefits of Eating After Exercise for Recovery and Muscle Growth Fat Loss Between Pre- and Post-Eating Exercise Routines Myth 4: You Can't Build Muscle & Lose Fat at the Same Time Body Recomposition Myth 5: Stick to One Meal Timing Strategy Forever Listening to Your Body and Adapting Your Approach Considerations for Optimising Performance Through Meal Timing and Exercise Avoiding Gastrointestinal Discomfort During Workouts Pros and Cons of Ice Baths for Muscle Recovery Conclusion Remember: the best routine is the one you’ll stick with. Related readings
Myth 1: Exercising Before or After Eating is Good.
Fasted exercise — as in, exercising first thing in the morning before breakfast — is all the rage for fat loss. But is that really the best way to go about it?
Benefits and Considerations of Exercising Before Breakfast
Some will defend to the death the power of black coffee and a fasted morning workout. Gentle exercise — such as a little brisk walk or a bit of yoga —can feel energising and give a sense of pattern. But working out at a high intensity, doing HIIT or lifting weights on an empty stomach, could make you feel faint or sluggish.
Pros of fasted exercise:
- It might feel light and energising for low-intensity activity (e.g., yoga, walking).
- It may help some women better stick to a routine by exercising before anything else.
- A black coffee before might promote alertness.
Cons of fasted exercise:
- High-intensity exercise (HIIT, weights) can be more difficult without fuel.
- It may cause lightheadedness and fatigue if glycogen levels are too low.
- It's not great if you get an out-of-the-gym craving or overeat later.
Impact on Fat Metabolism During Workouts
Fasted exercise may use fat stores, but it doesn't guarantee maximum fat loss for everyone. Without sufficient energy, you may not be able to push hard enough to create any real results. Moreover, skipping what to eat before a workout could mean muscle catabolism instead of fat loss.
Myth 2: Eating Before a Workout Will Make You Feel Sluggish
Skipping pre-workout meals can cause sluggishness; balanced carbs, protein, and fat boost energy and performance. Let’s break down the facts.
Recommended Meal Composition Before Exercising
Selecting a meal or snack before exercise is primarily about picking easy-to-digest foods that will sustain you through your session but will not bloat you:
Ideal pre-workout meals/snacks (30-90 mins before exercise):
- Porridge with banana (slow-release carbs and potassium)
- Wholemeal toast and peanut butter (carbs and healthy fats/protein)
- Greek yoghurt and berries (protein and fast-digesting carbs)
- A few dates or a rice cake with honey for a quick energy pick-up during intense sessions.
What to avoid:
- Greasy fry-ups or heavy, high-fibre meals (slow to digest)
- Sugary cereals or energy drinks (especially if the exercise is being undertaken at a high intensity)
Effects of Carbohydrates and Protein on Energy Levels
Carbs = The fuel tank for your workout
- Carbs break down to glucose to fuel your muscles during exercise.
- Choose a combination of fast-digesting (bananas, honey) and slow-digesting (oats, whole grains) carbs.
Protein = Energy sustained + muscle protection
- A small portion of protein (like yoghurt or nut butter) can help avoid fatigue during exercise.
- Don't eat large portions of protein before exercise because digesting it will take time.
Myth 3: Post-Workout Nutrition Isn’t Important for Fat Loss
You might think that not eating after a workout encourages faster fat loss because you just burned some calories, right? Well, you may be setting yourself back even further. Whether you exercise before or after eating, your post-nutrition choices are equally important as workout timing.
Benefits of Eating After Exercise for Recovery and Muscle Growth
Right after exercise, your muscles are ready to soak in nutrients to begin the repair and growth process. After exercise, a balanced meal or a snack (within 45-60 minutes) serves the purpose:
- Repair muscle (protein needed- Chicken, eggs, plant-based protein like lentils)
- Replenish energy stores (Carbohydrates like sweet potato or quinoa to replenish glycogen stores).
- Minimise soreness (Rehydration and electrolytes help to reduce passive recovery time.
Skipping refueling can cause muscle breakdown, slow metabolism, and boost cravings, undermining fat loss efforts.
Fat Loss Between Pre- and Post-Eating Exercise Routines
The ongoing debates about exercising before or after eating often miss the bigger picture. Fasted exercise may burn more fat during workouts, but studies show overall fat loss remains similar.
Why is that? Properly fueling after workouts will support:
- Increased metabolic rate (muscle burns more calories at rest than fat).
- Better performance next time (so you can push harder and burn more).
- Balanced hormones (so you do not overeat later in the day
So even if you fit a post-dinner workout, consuming a small protein-rich snack (Greek yoghurt or cottage cheese, for example) will assist recovery without counteracting your efforts.
Myth 4: You Can't Build Muscle & Lose Fat at the Same Time
A more prevalent fitness misconception is that you can't gain muscle and lose fat, meaning you have to choose to either "bulk or cut." But what if we said it is possible to do both? Body recomposition is doable, especially for women new to strength training or coming back after a break.
Body Recomposition
Body recomposition is losing fat and gaining muscle, resulting in a leaner, stronger body. While it is true that fat loss and muscle gain require different processes (fat loss needs a calorie deficit, and muscle gain needs a calorie surplus), the body can concurrently process both under the right circumstances:
Advanced athletes may have difficulty changing body composition (adapting to the training stimulus given more slowly). Still, women can usually make changes in muscle tone and fat loss. The key is to strike a good balance between exercising before or after eating so you can use it as fuel for the workout (i.e., a pre-snack rich in protein and/or a meal on recovery if a pre-workout is rich in protein) while keeping a handle on your overall nutrition and food intake.
Myth 5: Stick to One Meal Timing Strategy Forever
There is no one-size-fits-all when exercising before or after eating or for the same person daily. The notion that you must commit to one way of working out (for example, always fasting training or always consuming a full meal ahead of time) does not recognise the value of flexible meal timing. Energy levels vary, schedules vary, and exercise intensity varies daily; Therefore, why shouldn’t the fuelling strategy vary too?
Listening to Your Body and Adapting Your Approach
Body recomposition is losing fat and gaining muscle, resulting in a leaner, stronger body. Fat loss and muscle gain are different, but with proper nutrition and training, they can occur simultaneously in the right conditions.
- The "newbie gain" reaction occurs for new or returning exercisers because your body can dramatically respond to any form of resistance training. This means you can build muscle even when losing body fat (i.e., a slight calorie deficit).
- When eating sufficient protein, the recommended daily intake for muscle repair and muscle gain is 1.6–2.2g of protein per kilogram of body weight, which will help you stay full longer.
- Via smart training: Combine strength training (3–4x a week) with either moderate-intensity cardio or HIIT to promote maximum fat loss while sparing muscle.
- By prioritising sleep and recovery, Muscles grow at rest, and poor sleep can ruin your fat loss by producing excess cortisol (the stress hormone).
Pro athletes may have difficulty changing body composition (adapting to the training stimulus given more slowly). Still, women can usually make changes in muscle tone and fat loss compliance. Balance exercise timing with proper nutrition, like pre-workout protein or post-exercise meals, for fuel and overall health.
Considerations for Optimising Performance Through Meal Timing and Exercise
When exercising before or after eating, one can make better choices based on meal timing. Considering comfort, recovery, and joint health when choosing workout timing and nutrition can enhance your overall exercise experience and prevent injuries.
Avoiding Gastrointestinal Discomfort During Workouts
Nothing is worse than bloating or cramping that can halt a workout. To help reduce the risk of gastrointestinal discomfort while exercising:
- The ideal is to wait 2-3 hours after a full meal (30-60 minutes after eating a small snack) before engaging in intense exercise.
- Avoid fibrous or greasy foods before workouts. Stick with easily digestible, simple carbohydrates, such as bananas or white toast.
- Stay hydrated, but do not chug a large amount of water just before exercising.
Pros and Cons of Ice Baths for Muscle Recovery
Ice baths for muscle recovery are popular, but it's not all rainbows and sunshine:
✔ Pros: Ice baths can reduce inflammation and soreness after heavy exercise.
✖ Cons: If ice baths are used too often, they may slow long-term muscle adaptations.
Conclusion
There's no "right" way to exercising before or after eating. Your own personal tolerance and fitness goals are the best guides. Maybe you do your best workouts when you've fasted in the morning, or maybe you require something to get you moving before you can work out. Being conscious of what your body is communicating to you and remaining consistent is most important.
Ultimately, fitness is a matter of personal choice. Team "porridge before parkrun" or post-dinner exercise; just listen to your gut and enjoy the journey.
